| Platinum | Othello's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Benvenutis Restaurante |
| Silver | Prohibition Lounge |
| Bronze | Gaberino's Homestyle Italian |
| Top Pick | Bella's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Fontana Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Hideaway Pizza |
| Top Pick | New York Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Sandro's Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Sergio's Italian Bistro |