| Platinum | Boomarang Diner |
| Gold | The Brown Bag |
| Silver | Braums Ice Cream & Dairy |
| Bronze | The Garage Burgers & Beer |
| Top Pick | Bad Daddys Burger Bar |
| Top Pick | Mooney's Pub & Grill |
| Top Pick | Okie Tonk Cafe |
| Top Pick | Oklahoma Smoke BBQ |
| Top Pick | The Diner |
| Top Pick | Tuckers Onion Burgers |
| BillyGoat Grub |