| Platinum | Tarahumara's Mexican Cafe |
| Gold | Mamaveca Mexican and Peruvian Restaurant |
| Silver | Chelinos Mexican Restaurant |
| Bronze | Volcano's Mexican Food |
| Top Pick | Chuy's |
| Top Pick | El Huevo Mexi-Diner |
| Top Pick | Pepe Delgado's |
| Top Pick | Taco Casa |
| Top Pick | Ted's Cafe Escondido |
| Top Pick | Torchy's Tacos |